Thursday, February 19, 2009

The Easiest Way to Refold a Map

"The easiest way to refold a map is differently."
- Jones's Rule of the Road [1]


The minor difficulty of refolding a map are generally accepted without question, but there are folding possibilities most people are unaware of, and also possible hints that can be given to the user of a map.

Introduction
On a recent road trip I noticed a friend taking a moment to decide how to refold a map. Many have experienced a moment when they are faced with a sprawling map and mutter to themselves "let's see now...". Is there a better way to design these maps to save ourselves the trouble of having to figure out the right way to refold them? Can refolding a map be as straightforward as its unfolding? Yes and no. There are trade-offs, which we will explore below.

Several mathematical articles have been written about the combinatorial possibilities of map folding and unfolding (e.g., [2], [3], [4], [5]). When unfolding a standard map you are faced with a series of folded creases, and it is clear how to proceed. But when refolding the map, you see multiple creases, and have to choose not only which crease to refold, but in which direction to refold it. For a new map with bold crease lines, it is fairly easy to deduce how to re-fold it, but as the map becomes old and worn, this can become more difficult. Not surprisingly, people have found several ways to address this problem.

Why do maps need to be folded at all? Technology, including GPS devices and flexible map websites, such as Google and MapQuest, reduce the need for larger panoramas by providing us with alternate means of navigation or exploration of geographical relationships. Older means of solving the problem include the Thomas Guide series of map books, which display a different region on each page. But as long as there is a desire for broad panoramas in a convenient package, there will be a need for compact, foldable maps.

Fold Wisely
One method of facilitating map refolding is to only unfold only one section at a time. Others have sought out techniques of folding that work best for them. Many pilots or people in the military have established methods of map folding (e.g., [6],[7]). There is one widespread folding technique attributed to someone named Duncan MacKillop [8].

The original folding of a map can also be chosen to include non-intersecting creases. For example, if the creases are all parallel, so that the map folds like an accordion (also called a concertina fold), then refolding the accordion-folded map by alternating "mountain folds" and "valley folds" becomes trivial.

Add Helpful Hints
An idea I had while watching my friend re-fold the map was that maps could provide some type of visual (or even tactile) hints on refolding. The main surface of the map is prime real estate, so to speak. But could colors or symbols be added to the margins of the map to show the user which crease should be refolded next? At first it might seem that one could find guidance from the art of origami, which has evolved a sophisticated vocabulary, a collection of symbols, and even some impressive free software. But the context of the origami folder is significantly different from that of someone refolding a map.

In 1991, William Ferra filed a patent that covers the idea of providing colors along the borders of a map so that the user of the map can match up colors in order to see how to refold the map correctly. This idea could easily be extended to include shading, or numbers that correspond to the colors used. I have never seen a map that uses this technique, so it might be that map publishers don't see user demand for such hints as being sufficient to warrant inclusion.

Alternate Folding Techniques
Another technique called the Falk fold [10] (illustrated at http://www.instructables.com/id/Manageable-Map/) involves cutting the paper carefully before folding it into a book form with segmented, or tiered pages that can be bent downward to expose different areas of the page. This allows the user of the map to traverse the map book "latitudinally" by flipping pages, but also to navigate "longitudinally" by bending down the different segments on each page. The Falk company prints maps using this format, but those maps seem to be limited to areas within Europe.

An ingenious technique called the Miura fold (illustrated at http://www.instructables.com/id/Make-a-better-foldable-map/) was discovered by Japanese aeronautical engineer Koryo Miura. The seminal idea was published in 1970 [11], and the first map based on these ideas was printed in 1978 [12]. It involves carefully making non-orthogonal creases that work together to cause each crease to be folded or unfolded simultaneously along with all the other creases. This technique is called a miura-fold or miura-ori (or miuraori). Koryo Miura also wrote a paper on a type of fold similar to the Falk fold [13]. Maps using the Miura fold are printed by Patent Support Mates Co, Ltd. through the website http://www.miura-ori.com, and also by Compass Maps, which aptly calls them "popout maps".

Both the Falk and Miura folds obviate the need for refolding hints, but are more sensitive to careless handling than maps folded according to the standard technique, so they are often enclosed in a surrounding folder made of heavier paper, cardboard, or plastic.

Conclusion
Map folding is an everyday task that does not usually get more than a passing thought from most map users. But it is an area that we all experience at one time or another. Small improvements in usability might be most appreciated by a pilot flying in rough conditions, or a motorist lost in a remote neighborhood, but in the long run we all benefit from improvements that take a broad view of scenarios that might arise.

Also, innovations in one area often improve others. Innovations in map folding have found their way into the areas of satellite solar panels ([14], [15]), building construction ([16],[17]), and nanosheet design in materials science [18]. I wouldn't even be surprised if one day some applications of these ideas make their way into flexible furniture sold at your local IKEA store.

[1] Gardner, Martin. The combinatorics of paper folding. Chapter 7 of Wheels, Life and Other Mathematical Amusements, pps 60-73. W. H. Freeman, New York, NY, 1983.
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematics_of_paper_folding
[3] Map Folding. http://mathworld.wolfram.com/MapFolding.html
[4] Peterson, Ivars. "Folding Maps". In Ivars Peterson's MathTrek. 2001-01-15. http://www.maa.org/mathland/mathtrek_1_15_01.html. This reference cites [5].
[5] Arkin, et al., When Can You Fold a Map? 2000-11-20. http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/cs.CG/0011026. This reference is cited by [4].
[6] Folding an Aviation Chart. http://myweb.tiscali.co.uk/hirlehey/FoldingahalfmilUKaeronauticalchart.pdf
[7] Map Folding Techniques. http://www.armystudyguide.com/content/army_board_study_guide_topics/land_navigation_map_reading/map-folding-techniques.shtml
[8] MacKillop, Duncan. Everything You Wanted to Know About Map Folding. http://www.nodomainname.co.uk/duncanof.htm. Also available from other locations, such as http://www.listfaq.flyer.co.uk/mapfolding.htm.
[9] Ferra, William E. Compact Color-Coded Folding Map. US Patent 5160170. 1991-10-18.
[10] Falk, Gerhard. Method for folding large area maps into the shape of a book and correspondingly folded maps. US Patent 3143363. 1964-08-04.
[11] Miura, Koryo. Proposition of Pseudo-cylindrical Concave Polyhedral Shells, Proc. IASS Symposium on folded Plates and Prismatic Structures, Vienna. 1970.
[12] Olivetti Corporation of Japan. The Fun of Map Folding. 1978.
[13] Miura, Koryo. Design of Portale Paper Maps Enabling Longitudinal Access, University of Tokyo. Available at http://www.cartesia.org/geodoc/icc2005/pdf/oral/TEMA3/Session%207/KORYO%20MIURA.pdf.
[14] Silver, Daniel J. "Adjustable Truss". US Patent 5701713. 1997-12-30.
[15] Insane Origami! aka How to Fold a Satellite. (Video) Episode 69 of System. http://revision3.com/systm/origami
[16] Hoberman, Charles. Curved Pleated Sheet Structures". US Patent 5234727. 1993-08-10.
[17] http://www.hoberman.com
[18] Knowing when to fold: Engineers use 'nano-origami' to build tiny electronic devices. (Video) http://www.physorg.com/news154796282.html

Update (2011-09-28): Here are an interesting article and a video on folding shipping containers.
Update (2024-11-13): A video posted earlier today: How Many Ways Can You Fold a Map?

No comments:

Post a Comment